Both actresses are charming, and the first episode has some smart dialogue, but it's sabotaged by a glut of physical comedy, most of which doesn't work.
[Jennie] Garth looks distressed while crashing into tables and falling over couches. Slapstick works when played to the comic hilt, not coming off like you're actually killing yourself.
It's a tired, threadbare concept, whose only redeeming qualities are its female leads. But they aren't appealing enough to overcome a cavalcade of stale jokes and predictable physical comedy.