A typical next door boy Joe has comes across the most perfect women for him; the only problem is he is not confident enough to pursue her, that’s when his friends and family intervene to start their relationship.
It's got a stale premise, dumb jokes, [and] characters who exist only to remind you of other characters in slightly better movies.
Movies.com
April 04, 2011
It's not insightful or original about anything more than a generic self-esteem boost for goony dudes who dream of hot babes, but it's never not doing cartwheels to make you laugh.
The premise might work if the film were content to be a fairly undistinguished example of over-the-top gross-out comedy.
Quickflix
October 21, 2010
She's Out Of My League might be the most important romantic comedy of the past twenty five years. If only it was funny enough to warrant such an accolade.
Writers need to start shaking things up a bit. Have the couple split up for actual reasons. Allow them to see other people or go in a whole new direction. This ending has been done. This whole film has been done. The plot is tired. Let it rest.