Old Dean Winchester

Adam Benson

Castiel, Claire Novak

Leticia Gore Actress

Danny Carter

Atropos, Fate

Marlene

Detective Glass

Ajay

Irv Franklin

Seth

Margo Lassiter

Maggie

Mike Schneider

Sister Mathias

Shawn Harley

Tasha Banes

Pierce Moncrieff

Sergeant 'Sarge' Joe Phillips

Justin

Elka

Velma Dinkley

Jamie Plum

Travis Weaver

College Professor

Head Cultist

Waitress

Jennifer Tanaka

Nurse

Billy

Elizabeth

Diner Waitress

Tracy

Demon Henchman #1

Taylor

Anthony, Possessed Girl

Court Jester, Michelle

Yellow-Eyed Demon

Vagrant

Corporal Vance Collins

Ryan Silver

Blonde Trickster Girl

Father Davis

Renny Rawlings

Tammy

Esther

Frankie

Trish

Stoner

Joe Silver

Shapeshifter Supermarket Woman

Demonette #1

Wounded Teen

Brunette Trickster Girl

Bloody Mary, Mary Worthington

Young Priest

Alan

Jen

Nanny

Kim

Serge Ladouceur

Jacob

Jay

Male Angel

Demon #1

Demon #2

Dr. Weiss

Young Dean's Teacher

Man

Ghost Twin #2

Lily

Mandy

Hellrazor

Adam

Cop

Kristen

Second Angel

Minion

Demon #1

Demon, Miss Hagar

Zao Shen

Katie

Girl

Lilith

Ghost Twin #1

Dustin Burwash

Cosgood Creeps

Dipper

Russell Lemmons

Rose

Elijah Peterson

Lorraine Fox

Thomas

Dr. Avery Meadows

Phantasm

Nurse Dolores Glockner

Roger, War

Lisa

Azazel, Father Lehne

Joe Whitetree